Navigating IRS penalties after Boyle

Image Credits: UnsplashImage Credits: Unsplash
  • The Boyle decision emphasizes that taxpayers cannot rely solely on third-party professionals to avoid penalties for late filing; they are ultimately responsible for meeting deadlines.
  • The IRS grants penalty relief for "reasonable cause," including circumstances like serious illness or natural disasters, but reliance on a tax professional does not qualify.
  • Taxpayers can request penalty abatement by contacting the IRS, submitting Form 843, and providing documentation to support their claim for relief.

[UNITED STATES] The U.S. Supreme Court's 1985 decision in United States v. Boyle established a stringent standard for taxpayers seeking to avoid penalties for late tax filings. The Court ruled that reliance on an attorney does not constitute "reasonable cause" under Internal Revenue Code § 6651(a)(1). This ruling has significant implications for taxpayers and tax professionals alike.

In Boyle, the Supreme Court addressed whether a taxpayer's failure to file an estate tax return on time, due to reliance on an attorney, could be excused as "reasonable cause." The Court concluded that such reliance does not meet the statutory requirement, emphasizing that taxpayers have a personal obligation to ensure timely filing, regardless of their use of professional assistance.

Chief Justice Warren Burger, writing for the majority, stated that while hiring an attorney is an exercise of "ordinary business care and prudence," it does not relieve the taxpayer of the responsibility to meet filing deadlines. The Court's decision underscores the principle that taxpayers cannot delegate their legal obligations to third parties.

This decision has sparked significant debate over the role of tax professionals in guiding taxpayers through complex filing processes. While tax professionals can offer advice and ensure that returns are accurately completed, the Court’s ruling clarifies that they cannot bear the responsibility for the taxpayer's legal obligations. This has forced many tax preparers to reconsider the scope of their services and the expectations placed on their clients.

IRS Guidelines on Reasonable Cause

Following the Boyle decision, the IRS maintains that to qualify for penalty relief under "reasonable cause," a taxpayer must demonstrate that they exercised ordinary business care and prudence but were nevertheless unable to file or pay taxes on time. The IRS considers various factors, including:

  • Death, serious illness, or unavoidable absence of the taxpayer or immediate family
  • Fires, natural disasters, or civil disturbances
  • Inability to obtain records
  • System issues that delayed timely electronic filing or payment

However, the IRS specifies that reliance on a tax professional alone does not constitute reasonable cause. Taxpayers are responsible for ensuring that their returns are filed and payments are made on time, even if they have engaged professional assistance.

In light of this, taxpayers are increasingly encouraged to be proactive in managing their tax obligations. Many experts recommend maintaining close communication with tax preparers throughout the year rather than waiting until the filing deadline approaches. This preemptive approach can help mitigate potential issues and prevent penalties for missing deadlines.

Exceptions and Considerations

While the Boyle decision set a clear precedent, there are exceptional circumstances where taxpayers may be excused from penalties. For instance, if a taxpayer can demonstrate that they were incapable of exercising ordinary business care due to physical or mental limitations, such as incarceration, there may be grounds for penalty relief. Justice Brennan's concurring opinion in Boyle acknowledged that individuals who are physically or mentally incapable of complying with filing deadlines might have a valid claim for reasonable cause.

Additionally, the IRS provides penalty relief for first-time offenders under its "First Time Abatement" policy, which may apply even if the taxpayer's situation does not meet the traditional reasonable cause criteria.

Recently, there has been an increasing push to expand these exceptions, particularly for taxpayers who face challenges due to systemic barriers, such as access to digital filing systems or difficulties obtaining necessary financial records. Advocacy groups argue that the IRS should consider a broader range of circumstances that could affect an individual’s ability to comply, especially in marginalized communities.

Steps to Request Penalty Relief

Taxpayers seeking penalty relief should take the following steps:

  1. Contact the IRS: Call the number provided on the penalty notice to discuss the situation.
  2. Prepare Documentation: Gather supporting evidence, such as medical records, court documents, or proof of natural disasters.
  3. Submit Form 843: If relief is not granted over the phone, complete and submit IRS Form 843, "Claim for Refund and Request for Abatement," along with the necessary documentation.
  4. Appeal Denials: If the request is denied, taxpayers have the right to appeal the decision through the IRS appeals process.

It's important to note that the IRS does not grant penalty relief for all types of penalties. For example, penalties related to estimated tax underpayments are generally not eligible for relief under the reasonable cause criteria.

Taxpayers are also advised to consult with legal or tax professionals before submitting their requests for relief. In some cases, the complexities involved in presenting a "reasonable cause" argument require expert advice, particularly when dealing with nuanced situations like multi-jurisdictional filings or international tax issues.

The Boyle decision reinforced the principle that taxpayers bear the responsibility for timely filing and payment of taxes. While the IRS allows for penalty relief in cases of reasonable cause, taxpayers must provide compelling evidence that they exercised ordinary business care and prudence but were nevertheless unable to comply. Understanding these guidelines and taking proactive steps can help taxpayers navigate the complexities of tax compliance and avoid unnecessary penalties.


United States
Image Credits: Unsplash
July 8, 2025 at 2:00:00 PM

AI stock market hype is real—but here's the risk no one talks about

If you’ve been anywhere near the stock market in the past year, you’ve probably heard it: “AI is going to change everything.” The...

United States
Image Credits: Unsplash
July 8, 2025 at 1:30:00 PM

Why it’s time to close the litigation funder tax loophole

There’s a multibillion-dollar hustle hiding in the legal system—and no, it’s not just ambulance chasers or billable-hour lawyers. It’s litigation funding, the financial...

United States
Image Credits: Unsplash
July 8, 2025 at 1:00:00 PM

Medicare changes for retirees in 2026

If you thought Medicare was some distant, retiree-only thing that didn’t affect you until your hair turns gray—think again. A major financial shake-up...

United States
Image Credits: Unsplash
July 8, 2025 at 1:00:00 PM

Bank of America warns of emerging 'less for more' housing market pattern

The housing market is playing a weird game right now. If you've been casually browsing real estate apps or walking through showrooms lately,...

Image Credits: Unsplash
July 8, 2025 at 1:00:00 PM

New Social Security bonus and SALT deduction rules take effect

In the second half of 2025, the US government introduced two policy changes that don’t make front-page headlines—but should absolutely be on your...

United States
Image Credits: Unsplash
July 8, 2025 at 12:30:00 AM

Trump’s no-tax-on-tips plan sounds good—until you read the fine print

In June 2024, former President Donald Trump made a direct appeal to America’s service workers: under his future administration, tipped income would no...

United States
Image Credits: Unsplash
July 8, 2025 at 12:00:00 AM

Why the weak dollar isn’t stopping Americans from traveling

A last-minute summer flight to Rome might cost less than it did last year—but once you land, your dollar doesn’t stretch nearly as...

Image Credits: Unsplash
July 7, 2025 at 5:00:00 PM

Why ditching credit cards might be the financial flex you need

Most personal finance advice online sounds like this: “Use a credit card for everything, pay it off every month, rake in the rewards,...

Singapore
Image Credits: Unsplash
July 7, 2025 at 4:30:00 PM

How to get a personal loan with bad credit without wrecking your score

Let’s say you’re sitting on an unexpected bill. Maybe it’s a busted laptop you need for work, a medical emergency, or rent creeping...

Singapore
Image Credits: Unsplash
July 7, 2025 at 3:00:00 PM

What insurance do I actually need in Singapore?

For most Singapore residents, insurance is not just a financial product—it is part of how the country manages healthcare access, retirement support, and...

United States
Image Credits: Unsplash
July 7, 2025 at 1:30:00 PM

How to evaluate stocks with strong fundamentals

It’s easy to get caught up in the excitement when major analysts release their latest top stock picks. Between upbeat research notes, glowing...

Singapore
Image Credits: Unsplash
July 7, 2025 at 2:30:00 AM

Why a bank mortgage may serve you better over time

For many Singaporeans, buying a home begins not with browsing property listings, but with an entirely different kind of decision: choosing the loan...

Load More