In a landmark moment for post-war German politics, the far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) party has achieved a historic victory in the eastern state of Thuringia, marking the first time a far-right party has won a German state election since World War II. This unprecedented success, coupled with a strong showing in neighboring Saxony, has sent shockwaves through the German political establishment and highlighted the growing divide between eastern and western Germany.
The Rise of AfD in Thuringia and Saxony
The AfD, known for its anti-immigration stance and euroskeptic views, secured approximately 32-33% of the votes in Thuringia, significantly outpacing the center-right Christian Democratic Union (CDU), which garnered around 24% of the votes. In Saxony, while the CDU managed to maintain its lead with about 31.7% of the votes, the AfD followed closely behind with 30.6-31.4%.
Björn Höcke, the AfD's controversial leader in Thuringia, celebrated the party's success, stating, "This is a historic achievement for us". The victory in Thuringia is particularly significant as it represents the first time the AfD has emerged as the strongest party in a German state parliament.
Impact on German Politics and Coalition Formation
The AfD's success poses significant challenges for the formation of new state governments. Other political parties have pledged not to form coalitions with the AfD, potentially leading to complex and unconventional alliances. This situation is further complicated by the emergence of the newly formed Sahra Wagenknecht Alliance (BSW), which secured 8-10% of the vote in Thuringia and 12% in Saxony.
Alice Weidel, co-leader of the AfD, described the election results as a "requiem" for Chancellor Olaf Scholz's coalition government. The poor performance of Scholz's Social Democrats (SPD) and their coalition partners in these state elections reflects growing dissatisfaction with the national government's policies.
Factors Contributing to AfD's Success
Several factors have contributed to the AfD's rise in eastern Germany:
Economic Disparities: Despite recent improvements, eastern Germany still lags behind the west in terms of economic development and job opportunities.
Anti-Immigration Sentiment: The AfD has capitalized on concerns about immigration, particularly in the wake of recent incidents such as the mass stabbing in Solingen.
Disillusionment with Mainstream Parties: Many eastern German voters feel neglected by traditional political parties and view the AfD as an alternative.
Historical Context: The experience of living under the former East German regime has influenced political attitudes in the region.
Reactions and Implications
The AfD's success has elicited strong reactions from across the political spectrum. Omid Nouripour, a representative of the Greens party, expressed deep concern, stating, "An openly right-wing extremist party has become the dominant force in a German parliament for the first time since 1949, which causes significant worry and fear among many people".
Carsten Linnemann, the CDU's national secretary, reiterated his party's refusal to collaborate with the AfD, emphasizing, "We are very clear on this". However, Alice Weidel criticized this stance as "pure ignorance," asserting that "voters desire AfD to be part of a government".
The East-West Divide and Future Implications
The election results highlight the persistent divide between eastern and western Germany, more than three decades after reunification. Political scientist Christina Morina suggests that the AfD's success in the east is partly due to its ability to tap into a shared experience among East Germans of mobilizing through street protests rather than traditional political engagement.
As Germany approaches its next federal election in 2025, the AfD's strong performance in these state elections raises questions about the future direction of German politics and the potential for further polarization between east and west.
Challenges for Mainstream Parties and the Way Forward
The success of the AfD presents significant challenges for Germany's mainstream parties, particularly Chancellor Olaf Scholz's coalition government. The poor performance of the SPD and its coalition partners in these state elections reflects growing dissatisfaction with the national government's policies and internal conflicts.
Rethinking Political Strategies
To address the growing support for the far-right, mainstream parties may need to:
Engage with Voter Concerns: Address the economic and social issues that have fueled support for the AfD, particularly in eastern Germany.
Develop New Approaches: Explore innovative ways to connect with voters, such as local citizens' assemblies.
Bridge the East-West Divide: Work towards addressing the persistent disparities between eastern and western Germany.
The Role of New Political Movements
The emergence of the Sahra Wagenknecht Alliance (BSW) adds another layer of complexity to the political landscape. With its critique of the Berlin government and stance on military aid to Ukraine, the BSW has gained traction in eastern regions. Its success may offer an alternative for voters dissatisfied with mainstream parties but unwilling to support the AfD.
International Reactions and Broader European Context
The AfD's success in these state elections has drawn international attention and raised concerns about the rise of far-right populism across Europe. As Germany grapples with these political shifts, the outcomes may have implications for European politics more broadly.
Quotes from Political Leaders
Chancellor Olaf Scholz expressed concern about the election results, stating, "These are worrying results. We take them very seriously and will analyze them carefully".
Friedrich Merz, leader of the opposition CDU, commented, "The AfD's success is a wake-up call for all democratic parties. We must address the concerns of citizens more effectively".
The AfD's historic victory in Thuringia and strong performance in Saxony mark a significant turning point in German politics. As the country grapples with the implications of these results, the challenge for mainstream parties will be to address the underlying issues that have fueled support for the far-right while maintaining their commitment to democratic values.
The coming months and years will be crucial in determining whether this election represents a temporary shift or a more fundamental realignment of German politics. As the country approaches its next federal election in 2025, the lessons learned from these state elections will undoubtedly shape the strategies of all political parties and the future direction of German democracy.
