Workplace authenticity under scrutiny

[WORLD] The widely endorsed workplace mantra, "Bring your whole self to work," is facing increasing scrutiny as leaders and employees alike question its practicality and implications. While the intention is to foster authenticity and inclusivity, experts argue that this approach may blur professional boundaries and inadvertently lead to discomfort or disengagement.

The Allure and the Pitfalls

The concept of bringing one's "whole self" to work emerged as a progressive step towards authenticity in the workplace. It promised a culture where employees could express their personal identities, values, and beliefs without fear of judgment. However, as organizations strive to implement this ideal, challenges have surfaced.

Dr. Tomas Chamorro-Premuzic, a business psychologist, cautions against the literal interpretation of this mantra. He suggests that expecting employees to bring their entire personal identity to work can be counterproductive, leading to potential conflicts and discomfort among colleagues with differing views.

Similarly, workplace consultant Susan LaMotte highlights that the push for authenticity can sometimes demand more of employees than they are willing to give, potentially infringing on their personal boundaries.

The Leadership Perspective

Leaders play a crucial role in shaping workplace culture. While some, like Macy's CEO Jeff Gennette, advocate for employees to bring their authentic selves to work, emphasizing inclusivity and equity , others, such as venture capitalist Marc Andreessen, argue for maintaining professionalism and appropriateness in the workplace.

The key lies in balance. Leaders must create an environment where employees feel safe to express themselves without overstepping professional boundaries. This involves setting clear expectations and fostering a culture of respect and understanding.

Striking the Right Balance

Experts suggest that instead of encouraging employees to bring their "whole self" to work, organizations should focus on promoting a "best whole work self" approach. This concept encourages individuals to bring their most professional and constructive aspects to the workplace, fostering a positive and productive environment.

Additionally, establishing clear guidelines and expectations regarding personal expression in the workplace can help prevent misunderstandings and ensure that all employees feel comfortable and respected.

While the intention behind "bringing your whole self to work" is rooted in promoting authenticity and inclusivity, its implementation requires careful consideration. Organizations must navigate the complexities of personal expression and professional conduct to create a workplace culture that values both individuality and respect. By focusing on fostering a "best whole work self," companies can encourage authenticity without compromising professionalism.