Why We Can't Resist Buying What Celebrities Tell Us To

Image Credits: UnsplashImage Credits: Unsplash
  • Research shows that products endorsed by celebrities are chosen more quickly by consumers, indicating a higher level of confidence in those decisions, driven by psychological and neuroscientific factors. 
  • While celebrities attract and hold attention, non-celebrities looking at a product can lead viewers' gaze more effectively towards the item, suggesting different strategies might be more effective depending on the ad's focus. 
  • The study highlights that human and primate behavior towards following the lead of high-status individuals has evolutionary roots, affecting our decision-making process in ways that extend to advertising and beyond.

Exploring the magnetic allure of celebrity endorsements, it's evident why brands eagerly pay top dollar for a moment in the spotlight beside icons like Cindy Crawford with a Pepsi or Daniel Craig in a Belvedere Vodka campaign. The phenomenon where luminaries excel in merchandising has perplexed marketers for ages. A pivotal inquiry emerges: What makes consumers gravitate towards products simply because they are championed by celebrities?

Delving into this enigma, Wharton scholars have unveiled insights that transition the focus from mere star power to the realms of neuroscience, psychology, and evolutionary biology. Their pioneering study, "How Celebrity Status and Gaze Direction in Ads Drive Visual Attention to Shape Consumer Decisions," co-authored by Elizabeth (Zab) Johnson alongside Michael Platt, Simone D’Ambrogio, and Noah Werksman, sheds light on the intricate dynamics between celebrity endorsements and consumer behavior.

This investigation into marketing psychology embarked on deciphering the dual role celebrities play in advertising - enhancing product appeal while potentially diverting attention from it. Through meticulous eye-tracking and pupillometry, the study observed participants' reactions to mock snack food ads featuring both celebrities and non-celebrities. The findings are revelatory: products endorsed by celebrities not only captivate consumers more but also instill a swifter decisiveness, evidenced by less pupil dilation, a marker of reduced deliberation.

A standout discovery from the research was the differential impact of gaze-cueing between celebrities and non-celebrities. Interestingly, when non-celebrities in ads directed their gaze towards a product, viewers' attention followed, lingering on the item. Conversely, celebrity presences tended to monopolize viewers' focus, regardless of where their gaze fell. This phenomenon, known as "the vampire effect," suggests that while celebrities may overshadow the product, their endorsement significantly bolsters consumer confidence, subtly influencing decision-making speeds without necessitating prolonged product contemplation.

The underpinnings of celebrity persuasion trace back to evolutionary and biological instincts, where humans and their primate cousins naturally align with the choices of high-status individuals within their group. This innate tendency underscores the profound effect celebrities have in swaying consumer preferences towards products, even in the absence of strong pre-existing inclinations.

Recent trends in advertising have shown a pivot towards featuring ordinary yet appealing individuals, a shift that may resonate more with younger demographics like Generation Z, who exhibit a discerning approach to celebrity endorsements. The study's insights into the stronger gaze-cueing in non-celebrity ads, coupled with a preference for relatable realness, hint at evolving consumer expectations and the nuanced power dynamics in play within the landscape of modern advertising.

As the exploration of marketing psychology and neuroscience continues to deepen, with pioneers like Johnson and Platt at the helm, the future promises an even richer understanding of the cognitive and social forces that shape our consumer behaviors. Their work not only illuminates the efficacy of celebrity endorsements but also opens new avenues for leveraging the intricacies of visual cognition and social influence in crafting compelling advertising narratives.

In this era of advanced research methodologies, such as pupillometry and sophisticated eye-tracking, scientists gain unprecedented insights into the subconscious processes guiding our preferences. These technologies offer a glimpse into the future of advertising, where understanding the subtle interplay between celebrity influence and consumer psychology could redefine how brands engage with their audiences, making every glance and every choice a testament to the intricate dance between our minds and the media we consume.


Marketing
Image Credits: Unsplash
MarketingAugust 1, 2025 at 12:00:00 AM

Why content as a loyalty tool in B2B is still underestimated

In many early-stage B2B companies, content still sits in the wrong corner of the room. It’s often scoped as a creative output or...

Marketing
Image Credits: Unsplash
MarketingJuly 31, 2025 at 1:00:00 AM

The impact of AI on modern marketing communications

You can always tell when a business is bluffing. It’s in the copy. It’s in the pitch deck. It’s in the moment a...

Marketing
Image Credits: Unsplash
MarketingJuly 30, 2025 at 11:00:00 PM

The loyalty payoff of letting customers keep their returns

The first time I saw a DTC brand tell a customer to “keep the return,” I thought it was a one-off. Maybe the...

Marketing
Image Credits: Unsplash
MarketingJuly 30, 2025 at 7:00:00 PM

How ‘no-return’ refunds build lasting customer loyalty

We didn’t build our brand thinking about returns. Like many first-time founders, we obsessed over sourcing, packaging, price points, margins. We thought about...

Marketing
Image Credits: Unsplash
MarketingJuly 26, 2025 at 9:30:00 PM

Why shoppers have stopped believing exploding deals

Urgency used to move product. Today, it risks moving customers away. Ecommerce founders chasing conversion spikes are discovering something unsettling: their exploding deals...

Marketing
Image Credits: Unsplash
MarketingJuly 26, 2025 at 7:00:00 PM

How language shapes outcomes in business

Most founders underestimate just how much language is doing the work. Not the pitch deck copy, or the press release polish, or even...

Marketing
Image Credits: Unsplash
MarketingJuly 26, 2025 at 3:00:00 PM

Why consumers choose bad options—and how businesses profit

Let’s begin with a hard truth: consumers often choose the “bad” option not by accident—but because it’s the one designed to feel accessible,...

Marketing
Image Credits: Unsplash
MarketingJuly 26, 2025 at 2:00:00 AM

Why virtual influencers work—and when they don’t

The influencer marketing game has always been about managing perception. But with virtual influencers, it’s now about manufacturing it from scratch. These computer-generated...

Marketing
Image Credits: Unsplash
MarketingJuly 26, 2025 at 2:00:00 AM

How to avoid customer-segment collisions in your growth strategy

Startups don’t usually die from lack of demand. They die from trying to serve too many types of demand at once. In the...

Marketing
Image Credits: Unsplash
MarketingJuly 24, 2025 at 4:00:00 PM

How brands reframe embarrassment into empowerment

Some of the most effective products on the market are also the hardest to sell. Adult diapers, odor-neutralizing sprays, lice shampoo, colon cleanse...

Marketing
Image Credits: Unsplash
MarketingJuly 24, 2025 at 4:00:00 PM

What actually keeps audiences engaged

We used to think the battle for attention was a creative one. Sharper copy, faster cuts, brighter thumbnails. But that war ended the...

Marketing
Image Credits: Unsplash
MarketingJuly 24, 2025 at 12:30:00 AM

How the impact of attack ads on team performance is overlooked

When two companies go to war with attack ads, the public sees a spectacle. But inside those companies, something quieter breaks. Coordination slows....

Load More