[UNITED STATES] In recent years, the once-lucrative world of airline loyalty programs has undergone a significant transformation, leaving many frequent flyers questioning the value of their hard-earned miles and points. This seismic shift in the industry has not only affected travelers but has also caught the attention of government regulators. Let's delve into why airline loyalty doesn't pay off like it used to and explore the factors contributing to this change.
The Evolution of Airline Rewards Programs
The Golden Age of Loyalty
For decades, airline loyalty programs were a win-win for both carriers and passengers. Frequent flyers would often choose their preferred airline, even if it meant paying slightly more or enduring less convenient schedules, to accumulate points and enjoy perks. These loyal customers were rewarded with predictable exchange rates, allowing them to convert points into flights, seat upgrades, and lounge access.
The Rise of Dynamic Pricing
As air travel rebounded post-pandemic, airlines introduced dynamic pricing to their rewards systems. This practice, long used for cash fares, now applies to points and miles redemptions. The result? A rollercoaster of reward values that has left many loyal customers feeling burned.
Sean Brown, a healthcare IT executive with nearly 2 million miles on Delta, expresses his frustration: "Unfortunately, there's been a pretty seismic shift in the industry. That has really not sat well with me".
The Impact of Dynamic Pricing on Loyalty
Unpredictable Point Values
Dynamic pricing has introduced a level of uncertainty that was previously absent from loyalty programs. Depending on demand and timing, a flight might cost 500,000 points one day and 50,000 the next. This volatility makes it challenging for travelers to plan and budget their reward travel effectively.
The Devaluation Dilemma
Many frequent flyers have witnessed their carefully accumulated points lose value over time. An analysis by IdeaWorks found that, on average, mileage and point prices have risen by 28% since 2019. This devaluation has left some customers feeling cheated, as the rewards they worked hard to earn no longer stretch as far as they once did.
The Disappearance of Award Charts
To further complicate matters, most major U.S. carriers have eliminated their award charts. These charts once provided a clear reference point for how many points or miles were needed for specific routes. American Airlines claims to be "the only major U.S. carrier to continue offering an award chart to help guide members in mileage redemptions". Without these charts, travelers are left in the dark about the true value of their points.
Government Scrutiny and Consumer Protection
The changing landscape of airline loyalty programs has not gone unnoticed by regulators. In September 2024, the Department of Transportation (DOT) announced an investigation into major airlines' reward devaluation and dynamic pricing practices.
Secretary of Transportation Pete Buttigieg expressed his concerns: "One of the biggest concerns is devaluation. So the points are worth something one day and something else. Another is some of the hidden pricing where the value of rewards is unpredictable or is concealed".
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) has also joined the conversation. CFPB Director Rohit Chopra stated, "Our initial review of the fine print suggests that credit card companies and airlines have the power to quickly and dramatically devalue those points by making it more challenging to redeem them or by limiting the inventory that can be purchased with points".
The Airline Perspective
Airlines defend their dynamic pricing models, arguing that they offer benefits to consumers. American Airlines told Business Insider that dynamic pricing allows them to offer some flights at lower rates. United Airlines reported that since implementing dynamic pricing in 2017, roughly half of its customers have gotten flights "for fewer points than our fixed award chart offered".
Delta, Southwest, and American all emphasize that they offer no blackout dates for rewards, and some airlines have expanded the ways in which points can be redeemed. For example, Delta allows members to use points for premium drinks in Sky Clubs, seat upgrades, and checked bags.
The Shift to Cash Back Rewards
As trust in airline loyalty programs wanes, many consumers are turning to cashback credit cards instead. J.D. Power's 2024 US Credit Card Satisfaction Study found that most cardholders are now using cashback cards, citing their lack of fees and the ability to use rewards as a credit on monthly statements.
Meir Statman, a professor of finance at Santa Clara University, explains the appeal: "People figure out that those points for miles are not worth it. When I'm getting a thousand miles and I thought that it was worth a cent per mile and now I find that this is worth, God knows what, but surely less than a cent per mile, I may as well get 1% in the form of a dollar than in the form of a mile".
The Future of Airline Loyalty
As the landscape continues to evolve, both airlines and consumers are adapting. Some travelers are becoming more strategic, using tools like point.me to compare points values across different airlines and rewards programs. Others are diversifying their loyalty, spreading their business across multiple airlines to maximize benefits and minimize risk.
Gilbert Ott, director of partnerships at point.me, notes that dynamic pricing has its pros and cons: "There are some airlines that charge far less now in economy and just a little bit more in business. But because of the dynamic pricing, you have dates that are 500,000 points and a million points — because there's a seat now available with points on every flight, and there's only some dates where the lowest prices are available".
Navigating the New Loyalty Landscape
For travelers still committed to airline loyalty programs, here are some strategies to maximize value:
Stay Informed: Keep track of program changes and be prepared to adjust your strategy accordingly.
Be Flexible: With dynamic pricing, being open to different travel dates can lead to significant savings.
Diversify: Consider spreading your loyalty across multiple airlines or alliances to reduce risk.
Use Comparison Tools: Leverage platforms that compare point values across different programs to ensure you're getting the best deal.
Consider Cashback: If the uncertainty of airline points becomes too much, cashback cards offer a more straightforward alternative.
The golden age of airline loyalty programs may be behind us, but that doesn't mean there's no value to be found. As the industry continues to evolve, savvy travelers will need to stay informed and adaptable. While the days of predictable rewards may be over, opportunities still exist for those willing to navigate the new landscape strategically.
As Secretary Buttigieg ponders, "Should there be some publicly sponsored source of information that at least tells you what you can expect from the airlines?" This question highlights the need for greater transparency in the industry. Until then, consumers must remain vigilant and proactive in managing their loyalty strategies.
The shift in airline loyalty programs serves as a reminder that in the world of travel, as in life, change is the only constant. By staying informed, flexible, and strategic, travelers can still find value in loyalty programs – even if it doesn't pay off quite like it used to.
WhatsApp
Instagram
Threads
